called Zephyr aka dreamstar(2)7 born April 27th age 17 lives with her head somewhere in the atmosphere above the U.S. parents from Taiwan likes blue, wind, dreams, pastel colors, reading, writing, drawing, graphic & webdesign, potatoes dislikes tomatoes.






Oath features a scan of the character Yuffie from the game Final Fantasy VII; this particular scan comes from Crisis Core, the PSP edition of the game. It's an expansion of a banner that was previously made, as well as an experimentation in cropping and filtering techniques.


Layout. dreamstar7
Image. Anime Paper
Resources. one two three


About this Entry
Posted by: dreamstar27

Visit dreamstar27's Xanga Site

Original: 10/3/2008 7:23 PM
Views: 325
Comments: 6
eProps: 12

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site


Friday, October 03, 2008

the moral code of webdesign

 

I'm feeling slightly jipped and extremely guilty.

A couple of days ago a link exchangee of Dreamscape emailed me about an old Xanga layout I had on Skye Sanctuary.  It was extremely similar to one of the premade layouts on her site, and she asked for me to remove it.

To be honest, I'd completely forgotten about the layout because let's face it - how long has it been since I made anything for Xanga?  I had used her layout for "inspiration" (I know it now as "jocking," to put it kindly) - of that I was guilty.  I didn't take her images or anything like that, but I remember trying my best to replicate that particular layout because I liked the style, the image, the feel, everything about it.  It ended up being almost the same, with just a few differences.

So I deleted the layout and emailed her back explaining, and hoped against hope that she wouldn't remove me from her link exchange list because she was - is - a great designer that I really admired. (She still hasn't replied yet.)

Today I went and visited my neglected site and clicked around my link exchanges, just to see what I'd missed.  I came across one link exchangee who had updated with a new site layout that seemed....... very similar to Dreamscape's current.  One of the images was the same, and the affiliates display was extremely similar, and this line thingy to separate the header from the content that I spent days thinking up (unoriginal as it may be) was also very familiar.

My first reaction was, of course, anger, because that was just so unfair.  Then I was torn - should I email her about it and ask her to take it down, or not?  I've known this designer for a long time, back from when I still made Xanga layouts (on a regular basis, anyway), and it just felt wrong to call her out on it.  I mean, the similarities are there, but small, and I'm sure she knows what jocking is and just might not see it as such.

I kept being indecisive and second-guessing myself when it hit me - what I'd done to the first link exchangee (the one who emailed me) was a hundred times worse than what this second link exchangee had done to me.  What right do I have to ask that something that vaguely resembles my work be taken down when I myself am guilty of practically copying someone else's work?

In essence, I'm just a big, fat hypocrite.

 Posted 10/3/2008 7:23 PM - 325 Views - 12 eProps - 6 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

6 Comments

Visit toofarbroken's Xanga Site!
Hihi. Well... I still read your xanga but don't really comment. Sorry about that.

Anyway, I looked at your le's and well to say they're similar is a bit of a stretch. Yours looks 39593485793253 times better tbh. And I just don't see the similarities except for that image... which I'm sure is currently somewhat popular online. If I saw the two it would not occur to me that one copied the other.

Hopefully your other LE won't be upset you used her stuff for inspiration.
Posted 10/4/2008 2:30 AM by toofarbroken Xanga True Member - reply

Visit princess_serenity07's Xanga Site!

i think you're great... you accepted your realizations.. most people wouldn't even admit to the thought... you did. and toofarbroken says your layout is waaay better. you're still awesome... =) and i'm still using your layout! thanks so much... hope you feel better soon about the sitch! cheers! God bless! (^_^)

Posted 10/4/2008 3:44 AM by princess_serenity07 - reply

Visit HUNTRESS_CHERRYLIPS's Xanga Site!
You know you want me...
kisses ...
take care...
muuaakksss
Posted 10/8/2008 8:05 AM by HUNTRESS_CHERRYLIPS - reply

Visit happypenguin44's Xanga Site!
Did she credit you? Like INSPIRED BY blah blah blah

hahaa Don't worry!! Seriously I copy a lot of people's style... ahhh back in the good ol' days XDD; jkjk I still do, but to be honest, it's not like they created the concept first... you get what I mean? Well, it would be possible, but in our modern society... NAWWWWW!!! HAHAH Wait, I'm not even making sense XDD; It's fine, don't feel too bad. I mean in way, it does show how much you admire her work that you just wanted to try out the style and stuff o____o; Seriously, I don't think I'm making ANY sense.

If the similarities are really distinct, then email her. If not, why bother? Just a way to show how much she loves your style X]
Posted 10/8/2008 5:40 PM by happypenguin44 - reply

Visit Azn_Tempest's Xanga Site!
That happens all the time; don't fret too much about it. We learn from mistakes, and we grow from copying and redesigning.
Posted 10/25/2008 7:15 PM by Azn_Tempest - reply

Visit L0L_x3's Xanga Site!

**NEW READER.

That stuff happens time to time.

Oh and I adore your layouts. :D

Posted 12/13/2008 5:35 PM by L0L_x3 - reply


Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
  • Say it with Minis! (?)

Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to dreamstar27's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in dreamstar27's local time zone:
GMT -08:00 (Pacific Standard - US, Canada)